Background
I took the kids to orientation and then I received a call from school. It was Ms. Philips. She told me that she was moving GIRL to her classroom and she was calling to let me know that. I protested. The conversation went like this:
Teacher:
Hi, This is Ms. Philips. I'm calling because we're going to move GIRL to my classroom.
Me:
That's not a good idea. Her twin brother is in that classroom. She needs to be in the other classroom.
Teacher:
I see here that GIRL was in the Babies Can't Wait Program.
I'm the inclusion teacher at school and she will be better in my classroom.
Me:
GIRL didn't need Babies Can't Wait. BOY did. They're twins. They told me they would never come into someone's house and pay attention to just one kid. They explained to me that usually when one twin needs services, the other one does too - so GIRL also had BBCW services. But she was not the one that needed them.
They were both evaluated by the school before pre-k and neither of them qualified for Pre-K services.
Teacher:
I observed your family at orientation. Something happened and GIRL was crying. She took a long time to calm down.
Me:
No she didn't. She's 4. She got in a toy battle with her brother. They're twins. It's an attention thing. That's normal.
(You will see this exact scenario play out below. Boy and Girl get in an altercation. Both melt into crying puddles. Girl always cries louder and harder and takes a little longer to calm down when her brother is there. The formula is: A+B+C = D
A = room outside of the house with all toys that we don't have at home and new people
B = siblings in the same room
C = altercation over toy
D = both kids melt down, GIRL cries louder and harder and longer.
It's called sibling rivalry. The louder one get's the attention first. The louder one is the one that is hurt more and needs care first, hungrier and needs to eat first, gets more attention. They both know that from infancy. Google it. It's a thing.)
Teacher:
Ms. MOM that is NOT NORMAL!
GIRL will be better in my classroom. There are almost 25 students in the other classroom and GIRL needs additional attention that she won't receive in that class. It will be too much for them to manage and disruptive. There are currently 9 students and 3 teachers. With your two, it will be 11 students and 3 teachers. She will get a lot of attention in my classroom. She will be better in my room.
I know that's hard to believe.
**RR is restroom
Background
I took the kids to orientation and then I received a call from school. It was Ms. Philips. She told me that she was moving GIRL to her classroom and she was calling to let me know that. I protested. The conversation went like this:
Teacher:
Hi, This is Ms. Philips. I'm calling because we're going to move GIRL to my classroom.
Me:
That's not a good idea. Her twin brother is in that classroom. She needs to be in the other classroom.
Teacher:
I see here that GIRL was in the Babies Can't Wait Program.
I'm the inclusion teacher
at school and she will be better in my classroom.
Me:
GIRL didn't need Babies Can't Wait. BOY did. They're twins. They told me they would never come into someone's house and pay attention to just one kid. They explained to me that usually when one twin needs services, the other one does too - so GIRL also had BBCW services. But she was not the one that needed them.
They were both evaluated by the school recently and neither of them qualified for Pre-K services.
Teacher:
I observed your family at orientation. Something happened and GIRL was crying. She took a long time to calm down.
Me:
No she didn't. She's 4. She got in a toy battle with her brother. They're twins. It's an attention thing. That's normal.
Teacher:
Ms. MOM that is
NOT NORMAL!
GIRL will be better in my classroom. There are almost 25 students in the other classroom and GIRL needs additional attention that she won't receive in that class. It will be too much for them to manage and disruptive. There are currently 9 students and 3 teachers. With your two, it will be 11 students and 3 teachers. She will get a lot of attention in my classroom. She will be better in my room.
I know that's hard to believe.
**RR is restroom
AUGUST
My little girl loves positivity <3.
"awww, that's adorable.:
See the teacher's reply August 30th, below.
Mom, you are not on this team. We know what we're doing, thank you very much.
BUT - No bad behavior reports. Only for GIRL.
August 31st, 2021
GIRL's behavior is the worst. BOY is complaining the most.
September 2021
And of course, there would be no way that you could possibly send an email to me from GIRL withought also sending one from BOY! He would never allow that. So, here's the email from boy 15 minutes later. (Sibling rivalry.)
GIRL begins daily negative self-talk - "I'm so stupid, I'm so dumb."
Also pay attention to how BOY reacts in first grade when his teacher says she is disappointed. Remember, he witnessed and was affected by their experience in pre-k and was being affected by what his sister was actively experiencing in first grade.
This is the response I got:
This is the reason that they wouldn't transfer her to the other classroom when I asked them to. They were evaluating her while I was protesting, and I didn't know it.
It's very hard for people to believe me when I say that GIRL was targeted at orientation and then started receiving bad behavior reports from Day 1.
But right here on September 13th, the teacher tells me - "Once she has been here for 60 days...."
60 days from August 9th, 2021 - when school started - brings us to October 8th. On September 27th (below) they called me to have the initial teleconference to discuss the results of their 60 day observation.
THE INCLUSION TEACHER TARGETED MY DAUGHTER DURING ORIENTATION AND BEGAN SENDING HER HOME WITH BAD BEHAVIOR REPORTS IN FRONT OF HER BROTHER, FROM DAY 1. DO YOU BELIEVE ME NOW? BOY and GIRL WERE EVALUATED BY THE SCHOOL BEFORE PRE-K, FOR special-ed PRE-K SERVICES, AND FOUND NOT TO NEED ANY. BY THE VERY SAME SCHOOL.
They were EVALUATING HER FOR SERVICES WITHOUT MY KNOWLEDGE OR CONSENT from the first day. Because her pre-k teacher believed that she needed them from the very beginning based on her observation of them at orientation. So, they ignored me every time I told them "She never does this at home."
They presumed things like, "She always gets what she wants at home, or She always gets her way at home."* and continued implementing their intended behavior modification program to the detriment of both children.
*(You will see this below and documented as a repeating theme all the way through second grade. I am a single woman and SOLE parent of TWINS. As of February 2nd, 2025, I haven't been able to work since May, 2024 as a result of this school situation. There is no possible way that she could always get everything she wants. It's not logical.)
I did implement the most fabulous star chart system, even though we didn't need it - to try and help.
And in my daughter's case, she was in a room with her brother being left to fight with her brother every day and then get chastised for it. Every day.
This was MY pre-k experience, too.
I'll never get this time back and these are the memories and feelings.
October
Can we look at the substance of their arguments?
Dont look at me. Dont touch me. Don't touch my things.
It's very obvious sibling rivalry that was being created and fueled at school, and seeping into our home lives.
She BIT her brother in school two days later. (10/8)
SHE BIT HER BROTHER IN SCHOOL.
They've been in school for exactly TWO MONTHS.
In my house, they're barely yelling nonsense at each other because they've never been pitted against each other like this at home.
At home they feel safe when they escalate because,
"if you never let them get to level orange, they will never get to level orange".
We don't let them fight at home. They're only 4. All they should be doing is enjoying and loving each other.
Think of this like every other four year old. A four year old should be able to hang out with a group of 4 year olds without fighting.
GIRL and BOY CAN do that very easily. The caveat is that BOY and GIRL are SIBLINGS.
GIRL and BOY CAN hang out with a group of four year olds without fighting, so long as their sibling is not in the group.
NO OTHER CHILD HAS A SIBLING IN THE GROUP.
It's not fair to them.
Someone MUST manage the sibling rivalry when they are together in order for them to truly love and enjoy each other.
They are only 4.
They can't manage sibling rivalry themselves yet.
They should have been in separate classes in pre-k, and they wouldn't now, since Kindergarten, need to be in completely separate buildings to even function.
If they HAD to be forced into the same classroom, someone needed to be managing their sibling rivalry they way I do, at all times, because they were 4.
That didn't happen. They were pitted against each other, against my better judgement and request, for an entire year. And GIRL was demonized for the entire year.
They now need to be in entirely separate buildings to even function.
Their frustration tolerance and tolerance for competition was driven so low. They suffered from explosive rage as a result of this.
They allowed BOY to be bitten.
They allowed GIRL to bite him.
THEY WERE FOUR.
On the weekends, I am able to take them places and do things with them without any problem. My daughter is the sweetest girl in the entire world and she's being chastised in school every day for something which is beyond her control. Sibling rivalry. Please notice that NO OTHER CHILD is involved in these incidents. This eroded away their relationship so badly.
I trusted BOY and GIRL so much that on the weekends at 4 years old, they would wake up at 6am, go to the living room, and play all morning until I woke up at 9am. She BIT HIM in school!!! But at home, I sleep while they play for three hours.
This is becoming my every day life.
Also, please take notice -
emails from Roth are usually positive. Emails from Philips are mostly abyssmal.
They should have changed him and not given it any more attention than that. PERIOD.
They were fighting with each other on the bus every day.
They were FOUR.
BOY was getting out of his seat and going to the 5th graders in the back of the bus to pick fights. 5th grader realized he could infuriate BOY by calling him a baby in front of everyone (especially his sister). They thought it was funny. So almost every day, there was a fight with a 5th grader on the bus. For a whole year.
It's hard to convey how damaging this was for them as children, as people, and as siblings.
It's even harder for me to convey how damaging it was for me as a parent.
EVERY OTHER KID GOT OFF THE BUS AND RAN TO THEIR MOM.
MINE WERE RUNNING AWAY FROM ME. In pre-K.
This is their first real experience with school. It was a disaster.
She's eloping because she needed her mother. THAT'S how bad it was for her in there. She's not eloping because she's bad or she's not getting her way. She needed her mom. If you need any more proof that these behavior charts are incredibly damaging, the chart that she brought home on this day (10/25) wasn't even that bad...
But GIRL doesn't realize that.
GIRL just knows she had a bad day, her arm was grabbed, and she came home with a paper. She has no idea wth is going on.
These charts don't work.
Why WAS GIRL's arm grabbed?
Here we can see the previous theme play out.
She makes things for me when she is being really mistreated at school and I send back a little praise email.
Just as I did when class started, I asked for GIRL to be switched out of this classroom.
I was told that it was too late in the semester and they couldn't just switch her.
Notice the difference in tone based on the author of the email.
November
EVEN WORSE - It was all so unnecessary. We could have had the most wonderful experience - the same way we do every where else we go.
There is so much research to support everything I was saying and these women refused to listen to me.
What I find is very important here is this - YESTERDAY, November 18th, the last email after dismissal mentions NOTHING about issues at nap time or about spending nap time in Wagner's office.
Today, November 19th, I find out that yesterday afternoon was terrible. AND, she was sent to the principal's office.
Also, before anyone gets crazy, they were taking pics of each other in pajamas.
December
From above during orientation:
Teacher:
I observed your family at orientation. Something happened and GIRL was crying. She took a long time to calm down.
Me:
No she didn't. She's 4. She got in a toy battle with her brother. They're twins. It's an attention thing. That's normal.
No behavior reports, only daily emails.
Jannuary 2022
This is depression. They both go to bed at 7PM, on the dot, without exception.
FEBRUARY 2022
NOW - It's BOY's turn. I just told her I don't see any changes at home yesterday! Today, she's sending the request for assistance.
MARCH, 2022
APRIL 2022
When the giver of rewards (the teacher) denied her the biggest best reward, in front of her brother - in her "just turned 5 year old eyes" it was an affront on her, personally. And, after 8 months of this, her behaviors have escalated out of control.
She never does any of this. I don't even know what to tell them any more at this point. We went to Nickelodeon Resort in Punta Cana for a week. That place is loaded with sweet treats. I set limits with no problem.
This is devastating.
MAY, 2022
Page developed January 2025